Lee writes on pg. 13 of "Visualizing Elementary Social Studies Methods" that, "Children must understand that history is not based on a single narrative or a sole perspective." That is absolutely true. The fabric of history is woven with many different threads. What we learn the more we read about historical events is that people and places were impacted differently by various events. The Civil War is a great example. The battles of Vicksburg and Gettysburg affected the soldiers of both armies differently. Reading journal entries or letters from them that have survived over the years offer varying perspectives on what actually happened. That to me is the joy of studying history.
Lee's example of Eleanor Roosevelt and Mary McLeod Bethune and their friendship offers students a different look at race relations and politics in the 1930s and '40s. The educational treatment of that subject helps students feel as if they are part of the story. That same feeling of being connected to that story can happen through reading newspaper accounts of a community's history, or even better, oral histories of certain events that took place can certainly give students a greater sense of what it was like to live in the past and offer them an interesting perspective on what is happening today in their hometowns.
Whatever the case, storytelling is a powerful tool for teachers, and when used right, it can lead to a lifelong pursuit of historical truth, which can certainly evolve over time.
Great post and I love that you included a video to go with your thoughts. If history doesn't reflect one person's perspective then who writes history? How is it remembered? Imagine your students asking you these questions later on.
ReplyDelete